Spegal's Prime Cuts - Your Local Butcher

About Us

Spegal’s Prime Cuts is a family-owned butcher shop proudly rooted in Shelbyville, Indiana, serving Shelby County since 1957. For generations, we’ve been committed to quality, tradition, and honest craftsmanship. We specialize in exclusive Red Poll cattle and Berkshire hogs, offering a carefully curated selection of premium beef, pork, chicken, seafood, and eggs sourced from trusted Indiana farms.
With a strong focus on non-GMO and organic options, every cut reflects our dedication to freshness, flavor, and integrity. At Spegal’s Prime Cuts, you’ll find more than exceptional meats—you’ll find a legacy of excellence passed down through generations. Experience the difference where quality, community, and tradition come together. Visit us today.

Areas Served

Our Professional Associations

Chamber of Commerce
Homegrown By Heroes
Indiana Grown

What We Offer

Our Specialties include:

No Additivities
No Preservatives
Gluten Free Options
Family-Owned
Locally-Owned
Red Poll Cattle
Berkshire Hogs
Local Meats
Snacks
Catering

Our Services include:

We are known for being a Butcher Shop, but we have much more! Come in for our deli meats, butcher boxes, fresh cuts, take-home meals, lunch specials, snacks, gifts, wine and more!
With the colder months in full swing, we're excited to offer shaved turkey, ham, and roast beef!
Plus, we also cater events, bringing the fun with a selection of our delicious sandwiches—guaranteed to have your guests asking for seconds!
More fun on the rise, we are looking into a Growler Station so you can take home some of our favorite brews. For now, you can come in for quality like no other!
P.S. We’ll be on DoorDash soon so you can have our steaks, sandwiches, beef, chicken, pork, seasonings, and more delivered straight to your doorstep.

Our Products include:

Locally Sourced Meat : Non-GMO Chicken and Eggs, Frozen Beef, Pork, Seafood
Local Cold Cuts: Turkey, Roast Beef, Ham
Sandwiches : Ribeye, Chicken, Pork, Local Staple "Scurri Burger"
Cheese : Cheddar, Colby Jack, Pepper Jack
Local and Nationally Sourced Wine
Cold Beverages
Local Produce
Crackers, Pickles, Nuts
Pasta Noodles and Grits
Spices, Oils, and Dressings

Testimonials

On 7/29/2026 Salli Betz had this to say:
We had a private dinner at Spegal's this summer and it was amazing! Eleven of us drove down from the north side of Indy and we were blown away by the quality of the meal and the service. Everything was simply delicious. It was a perfect night and way to explore one of Indy's neighboring 'small' towns! We'll be back!

On 7/21/2026 Nathan Ferguson had this to say:
Great hometown butcher shop! Super friendly people. Stop in you won't be disappointed.

On 7/18/2026 nicholas watson had this to say:
I cannot say enough good things about their meats and selection. The quality is on a completely different level—everything is fresh, flavorful, and clearly handled with care. You can actually taste the difference in every bite, whether it’s steak, chicken, or anything in between. Since I started buying from here, I genuinely don’t want to go back to grocery store meat. The texture, the richness, and the overall cleanliness stand out immediately. It feels better knowing exactly where my food is coming from and that it’s been prepared properly. This has become the only place I trust for my meats now. If you care about quality, taste, and consistency, there’s just no comparison. Highly recommend to anyone who wants to upgrade their meals. Im heading there now to pick up some steaks and chicken to break out my new grill my wife just bought me!!

On 7/18/2026 Nicholas Watson had this to say:
I cannot say enough good things about their meats and selection. The quality is on a completely different level—everything is fresh, flavorful, and clearly handled with care. You can actually taste the difference in every bite, whether it’s steak, chicken, or anything in between. Since I started buying from my here, I genuinely don’t want to go back to grocery store meat. The texture, the richness, and the overall cleanliness stand out immediately. It feels better knowing exactly where my food is coming from and that it’s been prepared properly. This has become the only place I trust for my meats now. If you care about quality, taste, and consistency, there’s just no comparison. Highly recommend to anyone who wants to upgrade their meals. Testimonial written by Nicholas Watson on this site.

On 6/29/2026 John Dattilo had this to say:
We recently had the pleasure of a private dining experience at Spegal’s in downtown Shelbyville. What a treat! Dinner was spectacular with loads of attentive service from the owners and staff. We all felt like old friends by the end of the evening. Everything we ordered was exquisite, but especially pleasing was the shrimp cocktail appetizer (with tear-inducing sauce that rivals St. Elmo) and the smoked pork chop. The meal, the shop, and the quaint downtown were well worth the road trip. We’ll be back!

Contact Us

Spegal's Prime Cuts - Your Local Butcher
48 Public Sq Shelbyville, IN 46176
Phone: (317) 395-6516
Email: spegalsprimecuts@gmail.com

Where To Find Us

Payment Types Accepted

American Express, Personal Checks, Debit Cards, Discover, MasterCard, Visa

Our Hours

Tuesday: 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Wednesday: 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Thursday: 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Friday: 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Saturday: 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Sunday: 10:00 AM - 3:00 PM

News

Looking for high-quality, locally sourced meats? Spegal’s Prime Cuts offers premium beef, pork, chicken, seafood, and eggs sourced from trusted Indiana farms—plus fresh deli options, sandwiches, cheeses, and more. Built on generations of craftsmanship, every cut is prepared with care and quality you can taste. Stop by today or learn more: Visit Spegal’s Prime Cuts

Info

FAQ

What types of meat do you offer?

We offer locally sourced non-GMO chicken and eggs, as well as frozen beef, pork, and seafood. Our cold cuts include turkey, roast beef, and ham.

What sandwiches are available at Spegal's Prime Cuts?

Our sandwich selection features ribeye, chicken, pork, and our local staple, the "Scurri Burger."

Do you stock any beverages?

Absolutely! We are proud to offer an impressive selection of locally and nationally sourced wines and beers, alongside a range of refreshing cold beverages. Exciting news for wine enthusiasts—Spegal's Prime Cuts is the exclusive provider of Gullion Family Vines! That's right, you won't find it anywhere else. Visit us today to explore these exceptional offerings!

Can I find cheese products at your shop?

Absolutely! We carry cheddar, Colby Jack, bleu cheese and pepper jack cheeses.

Are there additional grocery items available?

Yes, we also carry local produce, crackers, pickles, nuts, pasta noodles, grits, spices, oils, dressings, and more!

What makes your meat different from what I’d find at a grocery store?

We focus on locally sourced, humanely raised meats with no additives or preservatives. Our beef comes from Red Poll cattle, our pork from Berkshire hogs, and we also carry non‑GMO chicken and eggs. That means better flavor, better texture, and transparency you can trust.

What’s included in your butcher boxes, and can they be customized?

Our butcher boxes are curated for convenience and value, featuring a mix of fresh cuts, frozen beef or pork, and customer favorites. Availability varies by season, but customization options are often available—just ask our team to build a box that fits your cooking style or freezer space.

What types of events do you cater, and what’s most popular?

We cater everything from office lunches and game days to family gatherings, featuring crowd‑favorite sandwiches like ribeye, chicken, pork, and our local staple—the Scurri Burger. Catering is done with the same high‑quality meats you know from our shop, so guests always notice the difference.

What’s coming next for the shop?

We’re always growing! We’re currently exploring a Growler Station so customers can take home some of our favorite brews. Plus, we’ll be launching DoorDash delivery soon, making it easier than ever to enjoy our steaks, sandwiches, meats, seasonings, and take‑home meals right at home.

Site Navigation